New Clause 5  Smoke-free premises: exemptions
Jim Devine (Livingston, Lab)Is this not a simple health and safety issue? Passive smoking kills. Full stop. It does not matter whether it takes place in private members clubs or in public bars. Is that not the case?
Patricia Hewitt (Secretary of State, Department of Health)My hon. Friend is right. It is also the case that about 95 per cent. of the deaths that result from passive smoking occur as a result of passive smoking in people’s homes, not in public places or in membership clubs.
Odd. If 95% of passive smoking deaths are caused at home, and this Bill doesn’t apply to homes, then a maximum of 5% of all possible deaths can be alleviated, 1 in 20, which according to the quote in the Minister’s opening statement amounts to “thousands of lives every year”. Saving a few thousand lives is a worthy cause, for sure, but will the Bill do so? Can it?
